Sense
& Sensibility
And
Pride
& Prejudice:
A
Comparative Study
Introduction:
Jane
Austen was belonged to the age of transition, from 1775 to 1817 i.e. of Sense
& Sensibility. The period of 1747-98 in the history of English Literature,
belongs to the precursors of the Romantic Movement. Jane Austen had, completed
‘Sense and Sensibility’, ‘Pride and Prejudice’ and ‘Northanger Abby’ in 1798.
She is more akin to the eighteenth century neo-classicist in her approach. In
the novels, her moral outlook and prose style favoured traditionalism. The
comparison between these two works, Sense & Sensibility, Pride &
Prejudice, confront us with social and political background, her style, theme
as well as the place of spinsters in the society.
Her novels
are specially based o love and marriage. Lets now have a brief on the
comparison of the novels.
Theme of Love & Marriage:
“It is a
truth universally acknowledged that a single man in possession of a good fortune
must be in want of a wife.”
This
opening statements strike the keynote of Jane Austen’s theme in the
novel-marriage in a society governed by economic considerations; as indicated
by the word ‘fortune’. Jane Austen’s usual theme is love and marriage. In all
her novels, there are beautiful girls waiting for really eligible bachelors to
get married to them.
In Sense and
Sensibility there are love stories of:
A)
Elinor- Edward D) Marianne- Willoughby
B)
Edward- Lucy E) Willoughby- Eliza
C)
Lucy – Robert F) Marianne- Colonel Brandon
While in Pride and Prejudice;
a.
Elizabeth – Darcy
b.
Jane- Bingley
c.
Lydia- Wickham
d.
Charlotte Lucas – Mr. Collins
The love
stories are related to the chief characters of the novel. Other stories are
co-related to them. These love stories provide interest to the readers. They
reveal the characters’ mind-set, their understanding, faithfulness and spirit.
realism and psychological aspects are woven with them. Lovers are tested and
rewarded. They fail and succeed but they become instrument to give us a second
background of the time.
In Sense
and Sensibility there is a little misunderstanding and delay in Elinor and
Edward’s marriage. The same happens with Elizabeth and Darcy in Pride and
Prejudice. Edward was believed in the love with Lucy when Lucy declared
that she is going to marry with Mr.Ferrars. Elinor was shocked by believing
that she(Lucy) is going to marry Edward Ferrars. But actually she married to
Robert Ferrars as she gradually falls in love with him after knowing that
Edward doesn't love her. Edward truly loves Elinor and the same thing he has
confessed to Lucy when she proposed him.
Elizabeth
has once refused the proposal of Darcy as his attitude is that he is offering a
prize which no woman can refuse this show his pride. Al, other characters of
Pride and Prejudice believed that Elizabeth is lucky as having him as a
partner. Thus, Elizabeth and Darcy begin with prejudice and gradually move
toward understanding. Elizabeth helps him to shed his pride and be the
gentleman. These develops love and feelings between them and then they got
married.
Marriane,
younger sister of Elinor falls in love with Willoughby. Willoughby was a showy
and flirty kinds of a person. He flirts with Marianne. Both wondered
everywhere as a couple. But Willoughby married to Sophia for her wealth. On
the other hand Colonel Branden loves Marianne. For her, marriage of Willoughby
proved a great shock and medium to realize reality. Finally, she marries to Colonel.
Lydia also
elop with Wickham. Their marriage is a very complex affair. Compatibility and
understandings are absent. She is affected towards Wickham’s personality nad
chivalary. She misunderstood her affection as love. Wickham has no mfeeling for
her. He was gambler with heavy debt. He thinks to marry other lady withwealth
to make his fortune. But as they elop, he has to marry with Lydia. She is
serious about their marriage. He married Ludia for unavoidable temptation of
instant financial help.
John and
Bingly are the most understanding and compatible couple among all the other
love marriage of the characters of both the novels. Both loves each other
sincerely. Both of them are sweet and gentle, easy going, unsuspecting,
understanding and willing to forgive reality. It seem through them Austen define
the best marriage, she imagine for others too. But their understanding their
marriage are fragile but they are happy because Bigly is too good to offend
conciously and Jane is to good to not to
forgive even some offence is caused.
Character Maps:
1. Of Pride & Prejudice:
2. Of Sense
& Sensibility:
However,
Jane Austen’s characters are unaware of the contemporary events. The motto of
Austen is to provide handsome husband to girls. They do not have any deep
spiritual, insight or religious attitude. Marriage & love is the central
theme of these both the novels.
Style of Austen:
It seems that Jane
Austen is aware about her potential and on the depiction on what come to her
range, creatively.
“I
would no more write a serious romance than an epic poem. I could not sit
seriously down to write a serious romance under any other motive than to save
my life... …I am sure I should be hung before I had finished the first chapter.
NO, I must keep to my own style and go on my own way.”
-Jane
Austen
(About
her Writing)
She adhered to her
range devotedly. Her range is extremely narrow. She worked on very small
canvas. The political changes and upheavals are absent from her writings.
Subject of science and philosophy also absent in the work.
The
society that depicts in Austen’s novels is middle class. Her work reveals the
society of upper middle class and middle class. Since this class was not
required to work, they are passing their time in dinner parties and dance
parties. The girls of these classes were not educated but they learnt music,
playing instrument like piano or violin, singing, needlework and knitting.
During those days girls could not get the part of her inheritance so the only
way for them to marry with financial sound guy. These qualities we can find in
the leading characters of ‘Pride and Prejudice’ and ‘Sense and Sensibility’.
Jane
Austen makes use of irony at different levels. She uses irony in
characterization to expose her characters’ misunderstanding of others as well as
their own self- depiction. But that irony is not with any bitterness, not
reflected any cynicism in it. But it makes us thinking over the significant
issues of life. So, the irony is neither indifferent nor irresponsible.
In Sense and Sensibility it is ironical
for the Marianne who is so feelingly, sensitive and romantic marries to Colonel
Brandon who is quite and sensible. Elinor who is practical in her approach
could not express her love when Edward proposed her. For Mrs John Dashwood it
is quite ironical that her sister- in –law marries to her brother Edward
Ferrars.
In
Pride and Prejudice the Bingly in Pride and Prejudice the Bingly sisters
mocks at the Bannets for their vulgarity but they themselves are vulgar. Darcy
proposes Elizabeth when she is hating her; Ludia has to marry Wickham who just
marries her for money just because she loves him! Elizabeth believes that she is not among the girl who
refuses the first proposal and accepts it on second proposal.
The
two virtues of ‘Sense and Sensibility’ and ‘Pride and Prejudice’ are constantly
juxtaposed each other. Isn’t it ironical?
Jane
Austen’s novels are hero less novels. Austen has given us very fine woman
characters. Elinor, Marianne, Elizabeth, Lydia, Jane, Mrs Collins, Mrs Bannets,
Mrs Dashwood, Mrs John Dashwood, and Lucy etc. her women characters are quite
different though she limits herself to certain matters in the novels. Every
character has its own individual nature. Austen fully draw them in very wide
fledge as the individual. Marianne & Lucy both are sensible and expressive
but having their own way. Similarly if we compare Elinor and Elizabeth; both
have their own way to think in a sensible way. Jane also sharing some
characteristics of Elinor but both are different individuals and their individuality
is clearly seen, very minute details are mentioned.
These
characters are not aware of any other social issues or the political issues.
They are concentrated on their own problems and life events.
Her
characters are revealed from compare and contrast. Edward’s relation and
honesty are revealed through Willoughby’s cheating for Marianne. Lady Catherine
and Mrs Bennet balance each other to their vulgarity as well as their
match-making manoeuvres. Elizabeth is compared with Jane likewise their very
nature.
Plot Construction:
There
is no moral or philosophical distractions, no obstersive characters, no loose
end or dangling ends. There is complete and knit woven plots and subplots. It
holds perfect organic unity.
The
main plot of ‘ Sense and Sensibility is
the love story of Elinor and Edward while in ‘Pride and Prejudice’ it is of
Elizabeth and Darcy.
Elinor
is the main character of the novel. Her attitude life-style, thinking, manners
and behaviour relate the purpose of the novelist. Elinor love to the Edward is
restrained. At Barton Park Edward’s long absence doesn’t disturbed her much.
Lucy’s episode is disastrous for her. But at the end the secret revealed thet
Lucy was married to Rbert the brother of Edward.
In
‘Pride and Prejudice’ main plot is Elizabeth- Darcy affair. Both met at Mr
Bingley’s renting of Notherfield Park, which Darcy first time proposed to
Elizabeth; she refused it. But
afterwards Elizabeth’s visit to Pemberly brings them still closer. Later their
relation is getting closer in such a way that they got married.
In
plot construction the linking of sub-plot, dramatic elements are very useful. Sense
and Sensibility has another chief character of Marianne. The love triangle
of the Colonel Brandon- Marianne-Willoughby is the subplot when Marianne is
helped by Willoughby; she informed by him. He was flirt but she could not
recognize him. These event are linked with Elinor’s love story in such a way that
it confirms the style of contrast in the novel. Sometimes it indicates what
would be happen to Elinor.
In
Pride and Prejudice the growing Jane-Bingly affair brings Elizabeth also there,
that Darcy gradually falls in love with her. The subplot contributes in the
development of main plot. Charlotte-Collins plot brings them together at
Rosings. Then the main plot leads to the climax of first half of the novel.
The
characters have dramatic moves as per the plot. They are stated below.
C Marianne
who is sensitive, intuitive converts into understanding and calm girl.
C Elizabeth
who has the pride for her understanding of other, gradually melt down and fall
in love with Darcy.
C Willoughby
who seems so romantic and carefree; dumps Marianna exploit Eliza and marries to
Sophia for wealth.
C Lydia
who is stubborn and short tempered behaves maturely when she is serious about
her relationship with Wickham.
These characters are
changed through dramatic situations. Sometimes it seems natural and essential
for the plot and theme. It keeps the interest into the novels.
Thus, Jane Austen is a
novelist nurture the novel very well. Although wide range of character, each character
has its own individuality without covered by other characters individuality. Both
the novels are worth reading.